Every project hits the same question early: hosted builder, WordPress, or a custom build? The honest answer depends on how often you change the site, who does the editing and how much of your business runs through it.
Ignore feature checklists. Ask what happens in two years when the person who built it is gone.
Start with how often you edit
If the site changes four times a year and holds ten pages, a hosted builder is defensible. You will outgrow the template eventually, but the cost of entry is low and you can launch this month.
If someone updates hours, menus, products or posts weekly, pay for a proper content model now. Retyping content into rigid template fields gets old fast, and it is how sites end up out of date.
The three realistic options
- Hosted builders (Squarespace, Wix): quickest to launch, no server to manage. Limited layout control, heavier pages, and moving later usually means rebuilding.
- WordPress: enormous plugin ecosystem and plenty of local help. Also the most common source of slow, compromised sites we are asked to fix. It needs disciplined updates and a short plugin list.
- Custom Next.js with a headless CMS: fastest pages, layout designed for your content, and clean code you own. Higher upfront cost, and you need someone to maintain it.
Four questions before you commit
- Can I export my content and redirects if I leave? Ask for a sample export, not a promise.
- Who owns the domain and hosting account, and whose email is the billing contact?
- How many plugins or third-party scripts ship on the home page? Every one is a future update and a performance cost.
- Can a staff member publish a page without calling a developer, and is there a preview before it goes live?
What we choose, and why
For most client sites we build with Next.js, TypeScript and Payload as the CMS. Pages load fast, the editing screens match the content, and the repository belongs to the client at handover. For a store-first business, Shopify is often the better call; we would rather say that than rebuild what Shopify already does well.
Whichever route you take, keep the domain, DNS, analytics and content in accounts you control. That single decision protects you more than any platform choice.